Birthday Cakes Milwaukee
Delicious and Customized Cakes Crafted Exactly to Your Order!
Aggie's amazing cake is also available by custom order to make sure every detail is exactly like you want it! The cakes below are visual examples of different designs you can choose from, but everything else can be customized: the decoration colors, cake flavor, filling, event type, and personalized message.  Any of the style options below can be used for any event, so if you like the look of one of our birthday cakes and want to use it for a graduation cake, that is no problem!  We do ask that you order atleast 48 hours in adance of your event for our customized cakes.  You can call, email or stop in the bakery to order between Tuesday - Sunday. If you need something quicker than 48 hours, please check out our Personalized QUICK CAKES. The cut-off time for ordering "completely a-la-carte" for weekend orders (Friday, Saturday and Sunday) are Thursday at Noon. After that time there may be restrictions in terms of available cake flavors. The pricing below is each cake's starting price which includes our basic cake flavors and buttercream filling, and premium flavors or fillings will incur an up-charge. We thank you for your business and look forward to making you an incredibly delicious and beautiful cake!
Birthday Cakes
BC #1 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
BC #2 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
BC #3 - Prices:
6" = $24.75
8" = $34.75
10" = $47.75
BC #7 - Prices:
6" = $40.75
8" = $47.75
10" = $62.75
BC #5 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $45.75
10" = $60.75
BC #9 - Prices:
6" = $45.75
8" = $52.75
10" = $69.75
BC #4 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $45.75
10" = $60.75
BC #6 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $45.75
10" = $60.75
BC #8 - Prices:
6" = $37.75
8" = $47.75
10" = $65.75
BC #10 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $28.75
1/2 Sheet = $55.75
Full Sheet = $85.75
BC #11 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
BC #12 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
BC #13 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $45.75
1/2 Sheet = $75.75
Full Sheet = $125.75
Anniversary Cakes
BC #14 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $40.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $115.75
BC #15 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $40.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $115.75
AC #1 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
AC #3 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $25.75
1/2 Sheet = $55.75
Full Sheet = $85.75
AC #3 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
AC #4 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
Graduation and Congratulations Cakes
GC #1 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
GC #2 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
GC #3 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
GC #5 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
GC #4 - Prices:
6" = $24.75
8" = $34.75
10" = $47.75
Baby and Bridal Shower Cakes
BBS #2 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $43.75
10" = $57.75
BBS #3 - Prices:
6" = $45.75
8" = $52.75
10" = $69.75
BBS #1 - Prices:
6" = $24.75
8" = $34.75
10" = $47.75
BBS #4 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
BBS #5 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $35.75
1/2 Sheet = $65.75
Full Sheet = $95.75
BBS #6 - Price:
Full Sheet only = $175.00
BBS #7 - Price:
Full Sheet only = $195.00
Religious and Inspirational Cakes
RIC #1 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $43.75
10" = $57.75
RIC #2 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $43.75
10" = $57.75
RIC #3 - Prices (Fondant):
6" = $45.75
8" = $65.75
10" = $85.75
RIC #4 - Prices:
6" = $45.75
8" = $65.75
10" = $85.75
RIC #8 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $39.75
1/2 Sheet = $69.75
Full Sheet = $99.75
RIC #5 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $34.75
1/2 Sheet = $64.75
Full Sheet = $89.75
RIC #9 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $39.75
1/2 Sheet = $69.75
Full Sheet = $99.75
RIC #7 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $34.75
1/2 Sheet = $64.75
Full Sheet = $89.75
RIC #6 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $34.75
1/2 Sheet = $64.75
Full Sheet = $89.75
Retirement Cakes
RC #2 - Prices:
1/4 Sheet = $42.75
1/2 Sheet = $75.75
Full Sheet = $115.75
RC #1 - Prices:
6" = $35.75
8" = $43.75
10" = $57.75
General Cake Sizing Guidelines
Cake Size                      Estimated Servings
6" double layer                                        8 - 12
8" double layer                                       12 - 16
10" double layer                                     24 - 32
1/4 sheet                                               15 - 20
1/2 sheet                                               35 - 50
Full sheet                                               60 - 75
AC #2 - Prices:
6" = $21.75
8" = $29.75
10" = $43.75
***Please note that all special order cakes must be picked up at our main Greenfield Ave location, as that is where all of our beautiful and delicious cakes are now being crafted. Thank you for your business!***
Standard Filling Options:
Buttercream
Chocolate Buttercream
Premium Tier II Fillings:
French Cream
Cherry
Banana
Mocha
Fudge
Cream Cheese
M&M & French Cream
Chocolate Chip & French Cream
Chocolate Chip & Cream Cheese
Any Flavor Fruit Filling & Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter Cream Cheese
Oreo Whip

Premium Tier I Fillings:
Raspberry
Strawberry
Lemon
Blueberry
Pineapple
Premium Tier III Fillings:
Fresh Fruit & French Cream
Cannoli Cream
Custard
Liqueur
(Bailey's Irish Cream, Sweet Rum, Spiced Rum, Amaretto, Brandy)
Tiramisu.
Standard Frosting Options:
Buttercream
Chocolate Buttercream
Whipped Topping
Premium Fillings:
Extra Charge Applies, Varies by cake size
Premium Frosting Options:
Extra charge applies, varies by cakes size
Cream Cheese
Fondant
Chocolate Ganache